Support Live Chat
Nov 8, 2017 in Informative
Quote to Introduce the Issue
Barnett (2007) commences his work Sexual harassment: Do gender and organizational status of harasser really matter? by pointing out that “Sexual harassment is one of the key issues in the contemporary business world as increasing incidences continue to be reported all over the globe” (Pg. 7).
In the ideal world, having knowledge on what sexual harassment entails is the primary step of preventing it from occurring. According to Conte (2000), this may be defined as unsolicited visual, verbal or physical demeanor of a sexual nature towards another human being to an extent of severely affecting the working conditions or creating an antagonistic working environment.
Reason for Choice of the Issue
It was vital to choose sexual harassment because it is one of the key ethical issues being witnessed in the present world of business. Many employees complain about sexual harassment from their bosses and other employees hence the need for discussion of this issue. The commonness of sexual harassment facilitated its choice for discussion in this paper.
In this context, it is of significance to point out one of the biggest cases of all times in relation to sexual harassment, Mitsubishi Motors manufacturing, 1998.
The company verbally abused women, subjected them to obscene jokes, used graffiti as well as demeaning behavior. At one instance a mail worker fired an air gun between a lady’s legs; there was an abusive environment that saw many females quit positions which would be replaced by males. Others were denied promotion for refusing to give in to sexual favors from immediate supervisors (Equal Rights Advocates, 2012).
From the above example, sexual harassment in the workplace can be categorized in two: quid pro quo harassment as well as hostile work environment frustration. Firstly, quid pro quo harassment can be defined as instances where an employee is expected to keep up with harassing behavior towards him or her with the aim of preserving his or her job as well as avoiding negative impacts for lack of ‘cooperation’. For example, a company administrator asking for direct sexual favors arguing that the employee has no option but to comply. It can also be informed of a supervisor requesting to meet up a junior employee outside the organization, making romantic advances during the meeting, and putting into discussion the benefits of being in a relationship in terms of job security among other vices (Sims, 2002).
According to Equal Rights Advocates (2012), hostile work environment harassment entails establishment of an abusive, antagonistic or intimidating work environment towards a specific employee. The harassment faced by the victim may be severe, all-encompassing and reasonably offensive. Such cases include the situations, when a partner at work is frequently making sexual remarks towards the other or when an associate continuously inquires from other people at work about an employee’s sexual life.
This paper explicates sexual harassment as one of the key ethical issues affecting employees within the organization. The paper also presents effective alternatives for both the affected individuals and the overall organization. Based on our example, we are better placed to point out various negative effects that emerged as a result of Mitsubishi’s Illinois plant creating a hostile setting for women since 1990 (Barnett, 2007, p. 59). According to the Equal Opportunity Employment Commission (EEOC), there are various laws and Acts each employer or manager ought to have in mind before engaging in sexual harassment. These include:
- Federal Law, whereby Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act makes certain entrepreneurs accountable when it comes to prevention and curbing of sexual harassment occurring within the corporate environment.
- The California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) forbids sexual harassment in employment.
A. Barnett (2007) asserts that sexual harassment determines some of the decisions that are made within the organization. This implies that some of these decisions would depend on whether the employee agreed or refused to give sexual favors. For instance, in the case of Mitsubishi, the management denied women promotion for refusing to give in to sexual favors and going further to use abusive language when stating their role in the organization’s goals; a male supervisor was heard saying, ‘giving a woman a high position is giving her the powers to urinate on men’(p. 213).
B. Sexual harassment affects the overall performance of employees within the organization because of unsafe working environment. From our case, we are in the position to point out that the conduct of Mitsubishi resulted to a serious economic injury when the case directed them to pay $34 million dollars in terms of damages. Additionally, repeated sexual comments normally make the victim so uncomfortable at work such that his or her performance declines greatly (Sims, 2002).
Ethical Issues to Be Addressed
- On an individual level, improper personal behaviors and attitudes among individuals need to be addressed to ensure that they comply with the required standards at an individual level.
- At the organizational level, ethical issues relating to the improper and undesirable conduct of the management staff and overall employees need the urgent address.
- At the societal level, ethical issues concerning deviation from the established morals and ethical standards need to be addressed.
- According to Sims (2002), individual employees have the alternative of reporting any cases of sexual harassment to the required authorities within the organization or outside the organization.
- Mitsubishi Ltd. has an alternative of establishing strong ethical standards that every employee needs to observe strictly. This implies that ethical standards should hold a firm position against sexual harassment.
Evaluation of Alternatives
In line with teleologicalism, alternative A is the best alternative because it would lead to provision of best outcomes for individuals. However, in line with the deontological view, the alternative may not be effective because it may lead to varied outcomes of rejection of the case or acceptability and support of employees. In relation to this, the law regulators normally advocate for regular training of all employees on ways of harassment and discrimination at the work place. According to FEHA, such training ought to be conducted after every two years (Equal Rights Advocates, 2012).
Teleologically, argument B would lead to the achievement of the required results because of its strong position on moral standards. On the other hand, deontological view would not agree that morals would be a better alternative as they would not be followed by everyone. In addition to training, it is significant for firms to foster moral awareness as well as negative effects of sexual harassment through such means as posters, videos or brochures among many other visual materials. The sole purpose of employing this means is to assist employees to identify the workplace harassment as well as notify others from different organizations facing same troubles (Equal Rights Advocates, 2012).
Alternative and Justification
The best alternative is to enhance communication systems within the organization hence giving the employees more chances of raising their grievances in an open manner. This alternative is the best one because employees would be free to say anything concerning contravention of ethical standards. This will lead to the alleviation of sexual harassment because of the open reporting channels.
The Perception of the Alternative
Notably, the organization, individuals and society would have a positive perception toward the alternative of opening up reporting and communication lines because of its effectiveness in the resolution of the matter of sexual harassment in business organizations.
Sexual harassment is one of the key ethical issues being reported in most business organizations. Notably, sexual harassment influences most decisions such as the promotion or demotion of individuals depending on their reaction.
Employees have the alternative of reporting any incidences; organizations have the alternative of putting in place strong ethical standards to govern operations, and the society has the alternative of ensuring the established ethical standards as stated to be followed.
The best alternative to addressing sexual harassment is to open up proper communication channels within the organization and give employees better opportunities for reporting any incidences (Conte, 2000).
Company Responsibilities to Employees
From the contest of sexual harassment against Mitsubishi Illinois Plant in 1990, Barnett (2007) asserts that, ‘an employer may satisfy the requirement of reasonable care to prevent sexual harassment by having and distributing to employees a policy prohibiting sexual harassment and informing employees how to make a complaint’ (p. 291).
- Preventing Prison Riots
- Moby Dick: Argument on Whaling
- Polyvinyl Chloride
- Islam and Judaism
- Innovation Ecology
Customer`s comment 14 days ago
Big thanks to your writing team for coming through for me with my last order. I didn’t give them a lot of notice, but they were able to come up with a superb paper for me. This is the kind of service that I love. Sometimes, I get forgetful, and I forget when my paper due dates are. It is so comforting to know that I can be in a rush and contact Essays-Writer.net and that you will deliver a great paper for me, no matter what. The fact that you include an anti-plagiarism report is great, too. I appreciate knowing that my work is totally original. Essays-Writer.net rocks!
Customer`s comment 5 days ago
Your writers are masters at time management. I turned in an order for four very difficult papers, and they were all written perfectly, even with the short deadline notice. Thanks, Essays-Writer.net!
Customer`s comment 10 days ago
Your writing company delivers for me every time. I have never been disappointed.
Customer`s comment 6 days ago
I was happy with the two essays that your writers did for me. Even though the subject matter was quite dense, they managed to come up with high quality work. This has been my experience with Essays-Writer.net, over the long haul. Each and every time I have needed a high quality paper, you have come through with outstanding writing examples for me. I am pleased to recommend your writing service to my friends and colleagues.
Customer`s comment 6 days ago
The work I received from your writers was much better than expected, especially considering the affordability of your services! This is so impressive! I wasn’t aware, previously, that companies like Essays-Writer.net even existed, but then again, I’m pretty sure you are the only one that is this good. I have heard a lot of bad things about other writing companies, but never a negative word about Essays-Writer.net. You are reputed as being the best, and I, for one, am convinced that this is true.Thank you for the outstanding job you did on my essay and research papers.
Customer`s comment 6 days ago
Thank you for the great paper! My professor gave me a high mark for it.
Customer`s comment 7 days ago
As always, your writers have completed another impressive paper. This time, the subject matter required a lot of research. They not only completed the research. They also documented it absolutely perfectly. It would have taken me months to write a paper this thorough and of this high quality. Thank you so much for your diligence. It was greatly appreciated.
Customer`s comment 5 days ago
I find your writing service to be staffed with serious professionals who understand the urgency of turning out great writing for your customers. I have ordered papers from you for a year and a half now, and each time, I have been given superb papers that were error free and interesting to read. I truly appreciate your efforts, and hope to continue to do business with you from this point forward. You deserve my loyalty, because you are certainly loyal to your customers! Wishing you all the best.
Customer`s comment 21 days ago
Once again, I have sat down at my computer, because I feel I owe you big thanks. There is just no way to express how grateful I am for everything you did to make my research paper as good as it was. My professor gave me an A+ on it, which is the first A+ I have received during my entire college career.
Customer`s comment 17 days ago
Now I know where to go when I need an excellent paper written on a short notice. I am very happy with the paper your writers just produced for me. It was absolutely perfect. Please thank the ones who handled my order and let them know that I will definitely do business with Essays-Writer.net again.
Customer`s comment 24 days ago
Dear Writers #0019, Thank you for taking such a good care of me. I apologize for being as picky as I was, but I was only reflecting the professor’s requirements. I couldn’t believe my eyes when I got my grades back. He gave me an A+ on the paper, which is almost unheard. The paper you produced for me included each and every thing that the professor had required. He is notorious for giving us next-to-impossible tasks to perform in his class, but you managed to pull it off. I don’t know if any other student has received an A+ in this guy’s class, but he simply could not find a single thing wrong with my paper! Yay! Thanks so much.
Customer`s comment 18 days ago
My professor told me that the essay you wrote for me was the best one in the whole class! Thanks for doing such a good job. Compliments from this professor are rare!
Customer`s comment 3 days ago
Dear Essays-Writer.net, You handled my rush order beautifully. I am still amazed by the quality of the term paper, because your writers didn’t have a whole lot of time to write it. Still, they did a great job and I’m happy that I chose Essays-Writer.net. Thank you for taking care of this in such an eloquent way.
Customer`s comment 21 days ago
Dear Madam or Sir, Thank you for your competence and high standards. My paper was wonderful! I shall recommend your writing services highly. You are far and above better than other writing services that I have used. Your professionalism, attention to detail, high quality writing and great prices are a few of the reasons why I will never use any other writing service. Thanks again.
Customer`s comment 5 days ago
I am getting ready to graduate in another week, but had to take a minute to jot this line because I want you to know what a help your writing service has been to me, especially during my junior and senior years. The work has been hard, and I have had to study virtually all the time. With you helping me out with my more challenging writing projects, I have been able to move forward and do well on my tests and other school projects. I will be forever grateful to you for your help, and I wish you continued success with your fantastic writing service. All the best!