Support Live Chat
Nov 8, 2017 in Informative
Arguments for Bilingual Education
Bilingual education is a subject of criticism by the mainstream media. People argue about this form of education, create, and spread misconceptions concerning a subject they have limited knowledge of. Bilingual education refers to the use programs that provide help to native students. There are three kinds of bilingual programs. The first one aims at teaching English to language minority students through immersing them in classes where English is the only instructional language. The second program involves teaching students in their home language while demanding that they enroll in classes where they learn English as a second language. The final program involves simultaneous teaching of students in their home language and English. The main objective of this curriculum is to help students to be proficient in English and be able to learn in the mainstream classes. This paper supports arguments that favor the existence of the bilingual language in an educational setting.
Bilingual education started in 1968 after the creation of Title VII of the Elementary and Secondary School Act. The purpose of the education was to help students who are not proficient in the English Language. This act sought to ease attitudes that people had against immigrants and their respective languages. Before that, immigrant students performed poorly in school, and most of them dropped out because they could not comprehend the language of instruction (White & Gayle, 1997).
The use of native or home language enables students to learn. The native language, usually Spanish, keeps immigrant students from lagging behind in their studies as they try to learn English. Students, who are adept in their home language, are equipped with the foundations of the language mastery. This implies that, they can easily learn a second language. Although writing and language systems differ across languages, the reading process is similar. The native language is the first language of instruction for a child. A good education should ensure that a child gets knowledge and this is the basis of other subjects. For instance, a student who is taught geography in the first language has background knowledge and will understand the subject better. It is vital to note that, literacy in the first language implies literacy in the second language.
Good bilingual programs provide students with the subject matter especially in sheltered classes. In the context of bilingual education, subject matter refers to classes meant for intermediate speakers of English. The native language is very important in sheltered classes because it makes the presentation of a subject matter to be easy. However, students who begin to study English should not be allowed in the intermediate classes because they may not get comprehensible input.
Studies done on programs that offer bilingual education have revealed that the grades of the students improve with every class. For instance, in a class where students are instructed in 80% Spanish and 20% English, there is a subsequent improvement in their grades. Thomas Wayne and Virginia Collier, researchers at George Mason University in Virginia, studied the effectiveness of bilingual education. In this study, students were instructed in both languages. They found out that students who are slowly introduced to English perform better than those who are immersed in English programs. They conclude that, two-way bilingual programs are the solution in closing the gap between the native and non-native English speakers (De la Pena, 1991).
In terms of costs, the double-bilingual programs are expensive. This is because the programs require vast materials, spacious classrooms, well-trained teachers, small teachers to students ratio and administrators. This is the best ways of teaching English to students who are not proficient in the language. Although the immersion program is cheaper, it is ineffective and makes students drop out of school because of lack of transition and eventual comprehension. If students do not understand the language of instruction, then they may not be in a position to get the content of the subject.
From a cultural perspective, bilingual systems try to embrace the culture of the native students. These students want to learn this language in order to get into the mainstream of the nation. Their diversity in language and culture only serves to enrich the cultural heritage of the nation. These programs will help them to feel accepted and the outcome is that they will be able to maintain their home language while learning English.
In America, bilingualism is embraced just as multilingualism. Educating students in second languages will make the US have higher education rates and performance as a nation. Learning in the native language is both a human and a civil right. In Lau vs. Nichols, a case presented to the U.S. Supreme Court in 1974, the outcome of the ruling stated that schools that did not acknowledge native languages were violating the civil rights of students (White & Gayle, 1997). States like California did not have special provisions under which both native and English languages would be taught.
Education of children should be respected and any violation should be treated with suspicion. The Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) has been passed in some states like Massachusetts and California. This act has some elements that do not embrace the learning of the bilingual language. ESEA demands that schools should focus on using English only and this may lead to high rates of dropouts from the elementary education. The use of English as an official language continues to undermine the unity of the American people not taking into account whether they are natives or immigrants (De la Pena, 1991).
Language has always been dynamic and very active. Its function is to communicate the needs of the society while expressing culture and integration. Learning a second language is very important because it helps the learner to step into the context of another culture. In this age of globalization, bilingualism can only lead to effective communication and negotiations with a person of a different culture or origin. A different language is very essential because it enables the learner to have a different vision about life, and immigrant students should not be left out. People are increasingly becoming more independent on each other. Bilingualism ensures the world unity, security, and comprehension of other cultures. It is vital to note that, poor intercultural insensitivity has been fostered by monolingual cultures. This can lead to lack of trust, hamper negotiations in places where compromise due to understanding could have been achieved. A system that incriminates the teaching of foreign languages closes its doors from globalization. For instance, only 10% of Americans are fluent in a second language while the majority has dropped their native languages. This should be reversed if the U.S. aims at playing a key role in the international development (Lang, 2009).
A rich culture ensures that there are people who have insight into foreign language, understand news articles, and can interpret everything within its context. On the social arena, a native language puts a student in the limelight. People want to embrace a native speaker in order to learn their culture, cuisine, and traditions. If students are taught to appreciate their native languages, then the chances of appreciating English are very high. Bilingualism has also been attributed to sharpen the cognitive skills of students. Finally, the embracement of bilingualism will lead to the creation of jobs for the well-trained instructors. Researchers in this field will allow to earn a decent income while fostering the expansion of language in the national and global setting.
- Preventing Prison Riots
- Moby Dick: Argument on Whaling
- Polyvinyl Chloride
- Islam and Judaism
- Innovation Ecology
Customer`s comment 10 days ago
Thank you for your care of my essay writing assignment. I have received a wonderful paper. It is amazing!
Customer`s comment 15 days ago
The fastest and the most accurate essay writing provider on the Internet! I admire your quality and speed writing! Thank you!
Customer`s comment 11 days ago
People should know about such a great essay site. I will broadcast it!
Customer`s comment 6 days ago
I did not know what an online writing service was before I started to use this one. It is a cool site. They deliver perfect papers for me.
Customer`s comment 30 days ago
Very good paper. There were no mistakes in it. Fantastic!
Customer`s comment 12 days ago
I did not know what to expect from this essay site. My friends told me to watch out as there were a lot of frauds everywhere on the Internet. My experience is quite positive. The service impressed me with its writers and high quality of writing.
Customer`s comment 16 days ago
I did not provide any instruction for writing my paper, just a title only! They created a perfect paper for me. That is very, very nice!
Customer`s comment 24 days ago
I found this essay website trying to cope with my research paper assignment. I just wanted to find some materials corresponded with my topic. It is a big luck that I use this service as I can finally find free time for myself and my family. Thank you!
Customer`s comment 27 days ago
I thought that essay sites could not really help anyone getting professionally written papers. However, I was wrong. This writing service demonstrates only perfect writing and professional writers. They have done a great piece of work for me.
Customer`s comment 27 days ago
Actually I am a kind of a coward. Therefore, it was always hard for me to make a decision. However, I am glad that I have tried your essay service. It is a pleasure to order papers here. The work you do is so great.
Customer`s comment 11 days ago
The essay site is designed very well. It is easy to find everything you need here. The quality of writing is very high. Moreover, the writers are always ready to listen to you and follow your instructions.
Customer`s comment 3 days ago
I doubted about the quality of my writing. However, the finished paper was well written. Moreover, it contained no mistakes. My tutor takes even the smallest grammatical mistakes very personally. Thank you! I passed it to the next level with your help!
Customer`s comment 18 days ago
I gave a writer a very short time frame, but he/she coped with my assignment very fast and I received it in time!
Customer`s comment 15 days ago
I just cannot find the right words to describe this essay writing provider. Everything is awesome here. Thank you!
Customer`s comment 19 days ago
There are many cheap custom writing services on the web, but their quality is not good. This is the only custom writing service I can rely on.